Even after a franchise-record-breaking start to his season, many Toronto Maple Leafs fans remain ambivalent about William Nylander. That, to me, is surprising. He certainly has given Maple Leafs fans much to cheer about with his great start. However, despite Nylander’s contribution, there seems to be a hint of ambivalence amongst the fans.
William Nylander is more than a contract conundrum for Toronto Maple Leafs fans. He’s a polarizing player – still. Some fans still don’t like him, even after his great start to the season. I realized he was not universally appreciated; however, I thought that was in the past.
Related: How Can Maple Leafs Auston Matthews Get Better?
William Nylander Is Having a Great Year
The subheading above is not news to Maple Leafs fans. As the team navigates through a season filled with ups and downs, the one player who stands out is William Nylander. Having what many consider to be his best season yet, Nylander is making waves in his contract year. He currently has put up 12 goals and 17 assists for a total of 29 points in 22 games.
Nylander’s offensive skill is evident, and he’s on pace for an impressive 48-50 goals and 100-110 points if he maintains his current pace. However, his outstanding performance still raises questions among fans about the looming negotiations for his next contract. Many fans wonder if Nylander is worth a $10+ million salary. Many believe he’s caught in a situation not of his own doing – that is how much other players have been signed for.
Some Maple Leafs Fans Are Rooting For Nylander, And Some Against Him
In reading readers’ comments at the end of hockey posts on different sites (which I do regularly), there is no universal support for Nylander among fans. While some argue in favour of his contributions to the team, others point out his defensive shortcomings. On the other hand, Nylander fans suggest that his plus-1 rating indicates the overall defensive struggles of the team rather than his flaws. His focus on putting up points seems evident, but questions linger about defensive commitment.
Comparisons with fellow teammates Mitch Marner and Auston Matthews earning higher salaries also spark debates among fans. Nylander’s supporters argue that he shouldn’t settle for less than what his peers signed for several years ago. However, detractors bring up instances where Nylander’s play, such as avoiding body contact in critical moments, raises concerns about his overall commitment.
Related: 3 Takeaways from William Nylander’s Record-Breaking Point Streak
Some Maple Leafs Fans Point to Other Players in Comparison
The comparison of Nylander to other players extends beyond the Maple Leafs’ roster to other teams’ players. For example, a player like the Florida Panthers Matthew Tkachuk comes up. Fans believe that Tkachuk also delivers consistent leadership and intangibles. He earns much less than the $10+ million Nylander is rumoured to be seeking, which raises questions about the Maple Leafs’ salary structure.
Then there’s the debate that Nylander’s next contract might lead to an impasse, potentially pushing him toward unrestricted free agency. The tension between Nylander’s potential $10 million-plus AAV and the Maple Leafs’ cap constraints is a growing concern, especially considering the hefty contracts of Tavares, Marner, and Matthews.
Fans Bring Up the Portion of the Salary Cap Going to Only a Few Players
The issue becomes more complex when historical issues with fans consider the Maple Leafs’ overall salary cap situation. Fans still question whether allocating significant portions of the cap to a few players is a sustainable strategy. And, Nylander gets caught in that age-old (it seems) argument about the team’s way of doing business. All this conversation leads to speculations about potential roster changes and the impact on team dynamics.
As the season progresses, Nylander’s performance will likely play a huge role in shaping the story around his next contract. Whether the team can balance retaining its core talent and making necessary changes to address team needs remains to be seen. The Nylander contract saga continues to captivate the attention of Leafs fans, leaving them to ponder the team’s future and the financial challenges that lie ahead.
On the other hand, there’s this one clear question. Given what Nylander has shown the NHL this season, would the team even consider not signing him – perhaps at any cost? It is not an easy question.
Related: Beneath The Surface: The Maple Leafs Best Player Is a Surprise